(Download) "Ex Parte Finkbohner" by Supreme Court of Alabama # Book PDF Kindle ePub Free
eBook details
- Title: Ex Parte Finkbohner
- Author : Supreme Court of Alabama
- Release Date : January 06, 1996
- Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
- Pages : * pages
- Size : 56 KB
Description
The plaintiffs George W. Finkbohner III and Sandra Finkbohner petition this Court for a writ of mandamus directing the trial court to compel the defendant Principal Mutual Life Insurance Company (""Principal Mutual"") to comply with a discovery request. The petition is granted in part and denied in part. Sandra Finkbohner underwent a surgical procedure to repair a ventral hernia. It appears from the evidence presented that this procedure was determined by Ms. Finkbohner's personal physicians and her medical insurer, Principal Mutual, to be medically necessary to correct an abdominal problem that had arisen a few months before, during Ms. Finkbohner's pregnancy. It also appears that Ms. Finkbohner's physicians submitted a request for a ""presurgery review"" to Principal Mutual, specifically referencing a procedure assigned code number 49560 — the procedure to repair the hernia. Principal Mutual later paid all of the expenses associated with this procedure. At the same time they repaired Ms. Finkbohner's hernia, however, her physicians also performed an abdominoplasty, or, as it is commonly referred to, a ""tummy tuck."" Ms. Finkbohner's physicians had apparently not mentioned this procedure in their request for the presurgery review, and Principal Mutual had not authorized payment for it. Upon receiving a bill for both procedures (one coded 49560 and the other coded 15831), and after consulting a cosmetic surgeon, Principal Mutual denied the Finkbohners' claim for expenses associated with the abdominoplasty on the ground that such a procedure constituted ""cosmetic surgery,"" which is defined in the Finkbohners' policy as follows: